A blog post within the parenting community has recently stirred up a lot of anger, with support both for and against what was written. Without going into too much detail, it was to do with some school children being promised a reward for good behaviour, but when one parent complained that it wasn't fair that their child couldn't have the reward, then for fear of litigation the reward was taken away from the deserving children.
Put like that, I think most people would agree that the situation is actually not fair for all those children who were promised a reward in the first place.
However as comments were left on the post, it was suggested that it was a child with special needs who was not being 'allowed' to share the reward.
I've always said that I'm a 'sit on the fence' kind of girl. It's not because I don't have conviction (I certainly do when it comes to my own children!), but more because I feel I try to look at everything from all sides of the story.
Recently I posted about the fact that my elder daughter was picked to go on a special school visit to see the Queen. Partly because she is consistently well behaved (although not overly confident or outstanding in her class, one of those who falls 'under the radar') but also party through lucky dip lottery. I was obviously delighted for her, but I know that there were other parents whose children were not picked, who thought that it was 'not fair'. I could sit back and say it's 'not fair' that I know my youngest child would never have been picked to go on such a special trip, as her disability would have made it very difficult for her and others. That's not bad behaviour though, she's not naughty, it's just how she is affected - is that 'fair'? No, and it obviously saddens me, but I wouldn't dream of suggesting the other children shouldn't have been allowed to go just because she can't.
Comments were suggesting this was what had happened in this case.
Lately
I have been commenting less on other 'big issue' posts as I think more
about the consequences of 'jumping on the bandwagon'.
I
know I've been guilty of it in the past - when you are passionate about
something, feelings explode and things are said which cannot be taken
back. It's true in real life as well as online, of course. My two
favourite expressions from my mum were 'if you can't say anything nice,
then don't say it at all', and 'don't write anything down on paper which
you wouldn't want to be read aloud and shared'. Obviously I've ignored
that advice a few times (sorry Mum!) but I do think it's generally good
advice.
The
trouble is, that we don't all know all the facts of any story except
our own. Having a child with special needs really has opened my eyes in
that respect. I know that before we got Sasha's diagnosis, I didn't
really have much of a clue about what autism was. I also wasn't really
aware of the vast range of special needs that some other children, and
adults have, and the complications to everyday life that go with that. I
wasn't faced with it, therefore I didn't have to think about it.
Most
families have their own problems to deal with, and this could be
anything - special needs such as autism, or dyslexia, or hearing issues,
or feeding/organ issues, but also right through to alcoholism, mental
illness, poverty, loss of loved ones etc. We can't necessarily see them
or know about all of them. Who's to say which of these issues is
'worse'?
I'm always a bit hesitant to jump in on something as the internet has a funny way of changing things and before you know it the story is not what it originally was.
ReplyDeleteI'm so happy for your daughter! To see the Queen?!? Oh My Gosh!!!
Yay! Not that she got very close to her at all, but it was still an honour :-)
DeleteAs Lizbeth says, the internet is bad at distorting things and I am certainly going to try and avoid 'emotional' debates where everyone jumps on the bandwagon in future. I like discussion but not when it gets like the one we're referring to. It makes me quite stressed to be honest. Deb
ReplyDeleteAnd the last thing you need is more stress! Focus your energy :-)
DeleteHi Steph, thanks for posting this, I won't add anymore, I've said enough already. I hope your daughter's class and school continue to accept and include her in a friendly way. We have been lucky with primary school. My Son is about to finish year 6 and that has been one of the lovely things, that the children in his class have basically grown up together. Most of them have known each other since nursery and they do, generally, accept each other. I am keeping my fingers crossed for High School, but am actually really quite nervous about it. - I feel a few more blog posts coming on...I hope she carries on doing well.
ReplyDeleteThanks. Yes we've been really lucky so far; glad to hear you have too. hope High School is better than you think it is going to be :-) x
DeleteI agree, I always try to see a balanced view too, and I love this post as I've been writing and thinking a lot about true inclusion recently.
ReplyDeleteThanks. Awareness is the aim of the game, and you are doing the most fabulous job of that - thanks from all of us to you!
Delete